Strawberry rhubarb pie is MY pie. The one that I would choose over all others. The one that I wait 10 months out of the year for and spend the other two hoarding rhubarb as if the apocalypse is upon us. I grow it, I buy it, I steal it from neighbors’ yards. Nothing stands between me and rhubarb in these late spring and early summer months.
Strawberry rhubarb is also the pie that carries the most memories for me. My grandmother made it and my recipe is a variation of hers. For some reason, pie gets more street credit if it comes from a grandmother. Add to that a Hungarian immigrant grandmother (though strawberry rhubarb has nothing to do with Hungary) and you have a legit legacy happening there. It’s become my mission to perfect this pie.
Truth be told, the original recipe was better in my memories. It needed a little enhancement, so I have spent the past few years adjusting the recipe in the hopes of perfection. The one thing standing in my way was the inevitable juice factor – my pie was delicious but habitually runny. I had almost resigned to the fact that it was just going to be this way until a happy little accident happened to me last week.
I was preparing a dessert that called for rhubarb to be coated in sugar. Somewhere along the way I didn’t get past this step and bailed on my plans for that particular dessert. A couple of hours later I decided to make a pie and found that the sugar had helped release much of the water from the rhubarb. I proceeded with my pie to find that it was PERFECT. I’m not kidding – compact, beautiful and not runny at all! This was too good to be true.
I made pie again my usual way. Delicious but runny.
I made pie again the new way letting the rhubarb sit in sugar ahead of time. Delicious and NOT RUNNY! If you don’t have the time, this probably doesn’t make or break the pie. But, it’s a great step to help prevent a super runny pie. The topping used here is the one that my grandmother used with her pie. It’s a great option for a quick and easy crumble top. You can also use the traditional crumble topping on this site if you want something with a little more body to it.
People, I have put the final piece of the puzzle together and I give you the best strawberry rhubarb pie recipe.